How to read this: My short, firsthand take on the exact Goumi booties we had: they stayed on and were my favorite. That's the part I can speak to, so I'm leaving the review right there.
The whole firsthand review
Here is the complete useful claim: the Goumi booties actually stayed on for us, and they were my favorite. That is what I remembered strongly enough to write beside the link. If you have ever opened a long baby-gear review only to hunt for the one sentence that answers your question, this is that sentence.
I am keeping the wording personal on purpose. "Stayed on for us" is an observation about one baby and one family's experience. It is not a promise about every baby, every movement, or every day. I also did not record a head-to-head test against a closet full of other booties, so "favorite" is my opinion, not a formal comparison.
The exact pair on our list
The saved product was the Goumi Kids Stay-On Baby Booties two-pack in Stripe Gray/Midnight, size 0-3 months. Those details identify the listing connected to my note. They do not tell you the exact age when we used them, and I am not going to guess. A size printed in a product name is not the same thing as a memory of when a child wore it.
If you follow the product link, check the current listing before ordering. Colors, pack sizes, sizing language, and availability can change. The link is there to help you find the item I meant, while the firsthand part remains the short note above.
What this note does not claim
I did not save a note about warmth, materials, wash results, durability, or how the booties fit compared with another brand. I also did not write down how often they came off, what kinds of outfits we paired them with, or whether the same pair worked through the full labeled size range. Those would all require memories or records I do not have in the source note.
That restraint matters on a shopping site. Product names and marketing copy can supply plenty of adjectives, but copying those adjectives into a personal article would make them sound tested. The only result here is the one I can support: they stayed on for us.
A practical way to use one small opinion
If staying on is the specific problem you are trying to solve, this pair may be worth putting on your own comparison list. Then do the ordinary checks that belong to you: look at the current size guidance, read the care and use instructions, confirm the return policy, and decide whether a two-pack in the available colors makes sense for your budget.
That is as far as my recommendation goes. I can point to the pair that worked for us without pretending one happy detail answers every buying question. Small reviews are still useful when their edges are clear. If your only question was whether these stayed on in our house, you have the answer. If your question is about anything else, this note tells you where more checking begins.